Finca La Valentina
Finca La Valentina is not one farm. At least two separate coffee farms use the name, in two countries, with no connection between them:
- Boquete, Panama — 12.5 hectares in the Horqueta area below the Barú Volcano, owned since 2007 by the Osorio Baxter brothers, planted partly to Geisha.1
- La Paz, Honduras — around 25 hectares in the Montecillos region, farmed by the Mejía family and sold abroad as naturals, anaerobics and honeys.2345
Both are sold under labels that read simply “Finca La Valentina,” so a bag on a shelf does not tell you which one you have. The country on the label does.
This matters here for one specific reason: the Best of Panama results archive carries a reported 2011 Best of Panama win for a “Finca La Valentina” Geisha — a claim that rests on a single buyer’s blog post and has never been corroborated. That thread is picked up below.
Finca La Valentina — Horqueta, Boquete, Panama
The land
The farm sits on the slopes below the Barú Volcano in Horqueta, in the township of Los Naranjos, Boquete district, Chiriquí province — the same corner of Panama that produces most of the country’s famous coffee. Its ground runs from 1,500 to 1,650 metres above sea level, and the whole property is 12.5 hectares: 9 hectares in coffee, the remaining 3.5 in timber trees (cypress, pine, eucalyptus) and citrus.1
The farm reports year-round temperatures of 15–20 °C and describes its own conditions as a balance of rain, shade and sun. Weeding is done by hand by local staff, with no chemical pesticides or herbicides, and two natural freshwater springs supply the property.1 That is a “no-spray” claim made by the farm through its retailer, not a certified organic status — no certifying body is named.
The family
In 2007, brothers Efraín Alberto Osorio Baxter and Benjamín Alberto Osorio Baxter bought the farm from Manuel Lorenzo, a Spanish immigrant who had worked the land for more than twenty years. They renamed it after their mother, Valentina Baxter de Osorio, who with their father Efraín “Tito” Osorio had pushed them back toward the family’s coffee tradition.16 Panama Coffee Club tells the same story, calling the property Plantación La Valentina.6
What it grows
Four Arabica varieties are named: Geisha, Red Catuaí, Typica and Pacamara.1 At least some Catuaí is sold washed — the process where the fruit is stripped off and the seed fermented clean before drying.7 The Geisha is the lot that gets marketed hardest, which is unsurprising for any Boquete farm: it is the variety that made the district’s name.
To verify — the reported 2011 Best of Panama win
The Best of Panama results archive on this wiki lists “Finca La Valentina Geisha — reported overall winner” of the 2011 Best of Panama, at US$70.25/lb, already flagged there as resting on one buyer’s blog post that cannot currently be read at the source. The research behind this note searched for that result independently and found nothing — no official competition sheet, no producer announcement, no trade-press report naming Finca La Valentina as a Best of Panama winner in any year. Neither the Café & Aroma farm profile nor Panama Coffee Club, both of which describe this farm at length, mentions a Best of Panama placing at all16 — an odd silence for a farm that had supposedly won the country’s flagship competition. Two open questions, then. Did the 2011 result happen? And if it did, was it this farm — the Panamanian one — rather than a similarly named entry? Absence of evidence is not proof it didn’t, but nothing found here supports it. Do not repeat the 2011 win as fact.
To verify — no scores, prices or certifications
No SCA cupping score, auction price or Best of Panama placing for this farm surfaced on any competition site or producer announcement. The land, altitude and family details above come from Café & Aroma, a Panama City online retailer, not from the farm’s own website — confirmed by reading both the farm profile and the store’s homepage, which describes itself as a marketplace carrying about fourteen partner farms and roasters.18 The information almost certainly originates with the owners, but it is published by a seller with an interest in the coffee.
Finca La Valentina — Montecillos, La Paz, Honduras
A different farm entirely, roughly 1,500 km away.
What buyers say about it
Every detail in this section comes from roasters and importers who bought the coffee, not from the producer or from a Honduran institution. Read it accordingly.
| Detail | Reported |
|---|---|
| Region | Montecillos, La Paz department, Honduras249 |
| Altitude | 1,600 m above sea level234510 |
| Size | 25 hectares, of which about 23 in coffee2345 |
| Producer | Carlos Mejía — name given variously as Carlos Mejía Rodríguez, Carlos Ernesto Mejía, or Carlos Mejias234511 |
| Varieties | IHCAFE 90, red and yellow Catuaí, Pacas234510 |
| Other crops | Bananas and citrus among the coffee3511 |
| Harvest | March–May4 |
The farm is described as having been in the Mejía family for four generations and named after Carlos Mejía’s eldest daughter — the same naming instinct as the Panamanian farm, and pure coincidence.2
IHCAFE 90 is worth a note of its own here. It is a Honduran-bred rust-resistant variety that the World Coffee Research catalogue rates at the very bottom of its cup-quality scale, and it very rarely appears in specialty lots. A farm selling it into European and American specialty roasteries is doing something slightly against type.
Processing
The same farm is sold under at least three different processing styles by different buyers, which suggests it splits its harvest by customer:
- Natural — cherries dried whole, fruit still on the seed.24
- Anaerobic natural — cherries picked ripe, dry-fermented in sealed conditions for three days, then sun-dried for 12–15 days. Fermenting without oxygen is a deliberate flavour technique; see Anaerobic fermentation.311
- Red honey — some of the fruit flesh left on during drying.5
Tasting notes published by buyers run to blackberry, strawberry, vanilla and dark chocolate at one roaster, red berries, dark chocolate and blood orange at another.23 These are marketing descriptors, not scores.
To verify — the whole Honduran section is buyer-sourced
No producer-run website, IHCAFE record or Honduran institutional document for this farm was found. Specifically unresolved:
- The owner’s actual name. Three spellings circulate — Carlos Mejía Rodríguez, Carlos Ernesto Mejía, Carlos Mejias.234511 Very likely one person; not provable from any primary document found.
- Whether the 25 ha / 1,600 m / variety list is independent. Several roaster pages repeat each other almost word for word — one importer description reproduced across shops counts as one source, not five.
- No Cup of Excellence or national competition placing for this farm appears in Alliance for Coffee Excellence results or any other competition record checked. Any claim that it has won or placed at Cup of Excellence should be treated as unsupported.
- No SCA cupping score from any buyer.
Notable lots / records
| Year | Farm | Lot | Score | Price | Auction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | Boquete, Panama (unconfirmed) | Geisha — reported overall winner | none given | $70.25/lb reported | Best of Panama — single-source claim, see above and Best of Panama results archive |
No other competition result, score or auction price exists for either farm in any source checked.
Related
- Panama · Honduras — the two countries the name points to
- Best of Panama · Best of Panama results archive — where the disputed 2011 claim lives
- Geisha · Catuaí · Typica · Pacamara · Pacas · IHCAFE 90 — the varieties named at the two farms
- Natural process · Anaerobic fermentation · Honey process · Washed process — the processing styles sold under this name
- Hacienda La Esmeralda · Carmen Estate · Elida Estate — the Boquete and Chiriquí farms with documented competition records, for contrast
- IHCAFE — the Honduran institute behind the variety on the Honduran farm
Official links
- (no official website found for either farm)
- Farm profile — Finca La Valentina at Café & Aroma, Panama — a Panamanian retailer’s page, the closest thing to an owner-supplied profile of the Boquete farm
- Collection — La Valentina Plantation at Panama Coffee Club
Footnotes
-
Café & Aroma — Finca La Valentina farm profile — confirmed via WebFetch ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7
-
Bodhi Leaf Coffee — Honduras Finca La Valentina Natural ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10
-
Kaffeekirsche — Finca La Valentina Espresso ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9
-
R Coffee — Honduras Finca La Valentina specialty coffee beans ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8
-
Café & Aroma — store homepage — confirmed via WebFetch; describes itself as a Panama City retailer of coffees from multiple farms ↩
-
Hayman Coffee — New Coffee Honduras La Valentina Available Now ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4